Remodel or Build New in Loomis? How to Decide What Makes Financial Sense

Picture a couple standing in the kitchen of their Loomis home on a Saturday morning. They bought the property years ago for the land: a couple of acres, a row of old valley oaks, room for a shop and maybe a horse or two, and that quiet, small-town feel that’s hard to find this close to Roseville. The land still feels like home. The house, though, is a different story. It’s a ranch built decades ago, with a kitchen closed off from everything, a hallway of small bedrooms, and a primary bath that hasn’t changed since the day it was finished. Every time they talk about fixing it, the same question comes up: do we remodel what we have, or tear it down and start over?

It’s one of the most common conversations we have with homeowners in Loomis and Granite Bay, and there’s rarely a one-word answer. But there is a clear way to think it through, and it starts with understanding what each path actually costs.

What the Numbers Really Look Like

When we price projects, we look at total floor area, garages included, not just the living space. On that basis, whole home remodels start around $250 per square foot. New custom homes start around $500 per square foot, with most landing somewhere between $500 and $550, and highly custom homes running $700 or more.

On a 3,500 square foot home, that puts a full remodel somewhere around $875,000 and a new build at $1.75 million or more, before you account for demolition, new utilities, and the longer design and permitting runway that comes with starting from dirt. So in most cases remodeling is the more affordable path. But I always tell people that cost per square foot is only the first chapter. The rest of the story is in the house itself, the land it sits on, and what you want your life to look like in it for the next twenty years.

When the House Is Worth Keeping

Going back to our couple in the kitchen: if the foundation is solid, the framing is sound, and the house sits on the lot the way they want it to, with the right views and a good relationship to the yard, the pool, or the shop, then most of what’s bothering them is finishes and flow. That’s exactly what a whole home remodel is built to fix. We can open the kitchen to the family room, rework the bedroom wing, build the primary suite they’ve been dreaming about, and bring the whole house up to date while keeping what already works.

There’s also a quieter financial reason remodeling often makes sense in California, and it’s one homeowners don’t always think about until we bring it up. When you remodel, generally only the new work is added to your assessed value for property taxes. When you tear down and rebuild, the entire new home is typically assessed at today’s value. For families who have owned their Loomis property for a long time, that difference can add up every single year. It’s worth a conversation with your tax advisor before you decide.

When Starting Over Is the Smarter Investment

Now picture a different version of that same house. Once we start looking closely, we find a foundation that’s failing, dry rot in the walls, and a string of additions from different decades that were never designed to work together. The layout fights them in every room, and nearly every wall would need to move to get what they want. At that point, a remodel starts to cost close to what new construction would, and they’d still end up with a house they’re compromising on.

That’s when building new becomes the better investment. It’s also often the right call when the goals have simply outgrown the house, such as a second story, a true multigenerational wing, or a home oriented completely differently to take advantage of the land. A new home gives you current energy codes, all new systems, and a floor plan built around how you actually live, which matters a lot if you plan to stay for decades.

A lot of homeowners aren’t really choosing between remodeling and rebuilding. They’re choosing between preserving what feels familiar and creating a different future for the property altogether.

What Makes Loomis Different

Loomis isn’t a typical subdivision, and some of the things we love about it are the same things that make construction here more nuanced. Many homes are on septic, and adding bedrooms or building new can trigger a septic review or even a replacement through Placer County Environmental Health. That alone can shift a budget, so it’s one of the first things we look at. Rural properties may also be on well water or have older electrical service that needs upgrading to support a modern home, EV charging, or a shop.

Wildfire is part of the picture too. Loomis adopted updated Fire Hazard Severity Zone maps in 2025, and if your parcel falls within a mapped zone, new construction and major additions need to meet wildfire-resistant building standards that affect everything from windows and siding to roofing, vents, and decking. Add in long driveways, slopes, heritage oaks, and setbacks, plus the Town of Loomis Building Department on one side and Placer County on the other for septic and well, and you can see why the same house can price very differently from one lot to the next.

None of these are deal-breakers. They’re just the kinds of things you want to know before you set a budget, not after demolition starts.

Why We Plan Before We Price

The worst way to make this decision is to grab a rough number per square foot and guess. Two homes of the same size can end up in very different places once structure, site conditions, and finish level are on the table. That’s why every Tankersley Build Co. project begins with preconstruction. We walk the home and the property, work through design with you, and build a detailed budget so you’re comparing a real remodel against a real new build, not two guesses. If you’re still deciding whether to buy a property in Loomis, our pre-purchase consulting looks at feasibility, permitting, and budget before you close, so you know what you’re getting into.

And once construction begins, you’re never left wondering where things stand. Every project kicks off with a meeting before work starts, followed by weekly owner’s meetings on the same day and time each week, with a live Buildertrend dashboard showing your schedule and budget along the way.

For our couple in the kitchen, the right answer might be a remodel that finally makes the house match the land. It might be a fresh start. Either way, the best decision is the one made with real information, and that’s what we help families get.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to remodel or build new in Loomis?

In most cases, remodeling costs less per square foot. Whole home remodels start around $250 per square foot, while new homes start around $500. A heavy remodel that moves most walls, replaces systems, and fixes structural issues can close that gap quickly, which is why a detailed preconstruction budget matters.

How long does each option take?

Most whole home remodels take six to twelve months of construction, depending on scope, permitting, and material lead times. New custom homes usually take longer once you include design, engineering, permitting, demolition, and site work.

Will tearing down my home raise my property taxes?

Generally, yes. In California, new construction is reassessed at current value, so a full rebuild is usually assessed much higher than a remodel, where only the new work is added. Confirm the details for your property with your tax advisor or the Placer County Assessor.

Do I need to replace my septic system?

Not always. But adding bedrooms, increasing the home’s footprint, or building new often triggers a septic review through Placer County. We look at it early so it’s in the budget from the start.

Can I live in my home during a remodel?

Sometimes, during parts of the project. For whole home remodels, most of our clients choose temporary housing because it’s safer, more comfortable, and usually shortens the schedule.

Thinking About Remodeling or Building in Loomis?

Tankersley Build Co. is a luxury remodeler and custom home builder serving Loomis, Granite Bay, Folsom, El Dorado Hills, and the greater Sacramento region. If you’re standing in your own kitchen asking the same question, we’d love to help you see both paths clearly before you commit. Schedule a discovery call to start the conversation.

Remodeling & Custom Homes Near You

Tankersley Build Co. designs and builds whole home remodels, additions and custom homes across the greater Sacramento region. Learn more about our work in Granite Bay, Folsom, El Dorado Hills and Loomis, or explore our whole home renovations and custom homes.

Steve Tankersley

Steve Tankersley is the founder and President of Tankersley Build Co., a design-build remodeling and custom home company serving Granite Bay, El Dorado Hills, Folsom, Loomis, Fair Oaks, East Sacramento, and the greater Sacramento region. A third-generation contractor, Steve earned his degree in Construction Management from Sacramento State University while working as a carpenter, then managed large-scale commercial projects across California before founding Tankersley Build Co. with his wife, Heather, in 2017. He is also the author of the annual Tankersley Remodeling Index.

Next
Next

Serrano vs. Wexford: Choosing Between Two of Sacramento's Premier Golf Communities