When families tell us they are looking for a golf community in the Sacramento region, two names almost always come up first: Serrano in El Dorado Hills and Wexford in Granite Bay.
On paper, they look similar. Both are gated. Both are anchored by a private golf course designed by the Robert Trent Jones Jr. firm. Both attract buyers who care about quality, privacy, and long-term value. And both sit within a short drive of Folsom Lake and the foothills that make this part of Northern California such a special place to live.
Spend a little time in each, however, and the differences become clear. We have been inside a lot of homes in both communities, and we have watched families choose one over the other for reasons that have little to do with the golf course. Here is how we would explain the choice to a friend.
Serrano: A Master-Planned Community on a Grand Scale
Serrano is one of the largest and most recognized master-planned communities in Northern California. Developed by Parker Development Company, it stretches across the rolling oak-studded hills of El Dorado Hills and has dedicated roughly 1,000 acres to open space, including trails, restored wetlands, creeks, oak groves, and greenbelts.
At the center is Serrano Country Club, whose Robert Trent Jones Jr. course works its way through the hills with dramatic elevation changes and views across the Sacramento Valley. The clubhouse is a social hub in its own right, hosting dinners, weddings, and member events throughout the year.
What makes Serrano unique is its range. The community is organized into a series of villages, some gated and some not, with homes ranging from family-sized production homes to golf course residences and fully custom estates. That variety allows families to find the right home at the right stage of life without ever leaving the community.
Serrano is also known for its thoughtful infrastructure. Beginning in 1999, the community expanded its use of recycled water to irrigate not only the golf course and parks but many residents' front and back yards through a separate purple-pipe system.
Wexford: Intimate, Guard-Gated, and Fully Custom
Wexford is a very different experience. Located in Granite Bay, it is a guard-gated enclave of roughly 145 custom-built homes set across about 124 tree-studded acres. Homes range from about 3,350 square feet to nearly 10,000 square feet, and almost every one was individually designed.
Golf is part of daily life here, too. Residents enjoy golf-cart access to Granite Bay Golf Club, a private course designed by Kyle Phillips while he was lead architect for Robert Trent Jones Jr. The community also offers private tennis and pickleball courts, and families benefit from the highly regarded Eureka Union School District.
Where Serrano feels like a small town, Wexford feels like a private neighborhood. The streets are quieter, the lots are generous, and the community has a sense of seclusion that is rare this close to Roseville, Folsom, and Interstate 80.
How the Lifestyles Compare
The simplest way to think about the difference is scale.
Serrano offers more of everything: more homes, more trails, more village choices, and more price points. It suits families who want an active, connected community with a wide mix of neighbors and amenities.
Wexford offers less, intentionally. Fewer homes, a single guarded gate, and fully custom architecture create an exclusive, low-traffic environment. It suits families who value privacy and want a true estate setting with golf at the end of the street.
Commute patterns matter as well. Serrano sits along the Highway 50 corridor, making it convenient for families who work in Folsom, Rancho Cordova, or downtown Sacramento. Wexford is closer to Douglas Boulevard and Interstate 80, which makes Roseville and the Placer County job centers an easy drive.
Both communities have homeowners associations, and buyers should review fees, rules, and any special assessments carefully. Club membership is typically separate from living in either community, so it is worth asking about membership categories and availability before you buy.
What About Rancho Murieta, Granite Bay, and Beyond?
Serrano and Wexford are not the only options. Rancho Murieta, southeast of Rancho Cordova, offers a gated country club lifestyle with two 18-hole courses and a more rural, equestrian-friendly setting. Families in Shingle Springs and the broader El Dorado County foothills often find larger lots and more privacy, while the established neighborhoods surrounding Granite Bay Golf Club outside Wexford offer custom homes without guard-gated HOA requirements.
The right answer depends on where you work, where your children go to school, and how much community versus privacy you want.
A Builder's Perspective: What You Are Really Buying
Here is the part most community comparisons leave out.
Many of the homes in both Serrano and Wexford were built in the 1990s and 2000s. They were beautiful when they were completed, and most have excellent bones, generous lots, and incredible settings. But kitchens, primary bathrooms, windows, lighting, and mechanical systems from that era rarely match the way families want to live today.
That is why we encourage buyers to evaluate a home in two parts: the location you cannot change, and the interior you can. In both communities, the location is the scarce asset. It is often smarter to buy the right lot on the right street and plan a remodel than to settle for a newer interior in the wrong place.
If you go that route, a few things are worth knowing.
HOA architectural review is real. Exterior changes, additions, windows, roofing, and landscaping usually require approval. In our experience, building HOA review into the preconstruction schedule from day one prevents delays later. We recently navigated the same process on our Wyndgate whole-home remodel in a private gated enclave in Sacramento's Wilhaggin neighborhood.
Permitting timelines vary by county. Serrano is in El Dorado County, while Wexford is in Placer County, where permit reviews averaged eight to twelve weeks in our most recent data.
Budget for what you cannot see. Homes of this age often need panel upgrades, updated HVAC, and plumbing work once walls are opened, especially as California's electrification requirements reshape remodel scopes.
What Remodeling Costs in Communities Like These
According to the 2026 Tankersley Remodeling Index, a design-forward kitchen remodel in the greater Sacramento region typically ranges from $148,000 to $342,481, a primary bath from $88,245 to $196,518, and a whole-home remodel from $249 to $443 per square foot. For the larger custom homes common in Wexford and Serrano's estate villages, whole-home projects frequently reach the upper end of those ranges because of square footage, finish levels, and systems scope.
Those numbers are not meant to discourage anyone. They are meant to help buyers understand the true cost of a home before they make an offer, rather than after they move in.
The Best Community Is the One That Fits Your Life
Serrano and Wexford are both exceptional places to live. One offers a vibrant, master-planned community with something for everyone. The other offers a rare, private estate setting with golf just a cart ride away. Neither is better. They are simply different.
At Tankersley Build Co., we have helped families in both communities turn well-located homes into homes that finally fit the way they live. If you are considering a purchase in Serrano, Wexford, or any of the golf communities around Granite Bay and El Dorado Hills, we are happy to walk the home with you and help you understand what it would take to make it yours.
Ready to Start Planning?
Whether you are planning a kitchen, a primary suite, an addition, or a whole-home remodel, the best time to talk with a builder is before the design is finished. Start by reviewing the Tankersley Remodeling Index for current cost ranges and timelines, then schedule a discovery call with our team. We will talk through your goals, timeline, and investment range and help you decide on the right next step.